Hiring your first employees: the complete US guide from EIN to the first 90 days
A step-by-step US guide to hiring your first employees: employee or contractor, EIN and state setup, fair recruiting, interviews, new-hire forms, payroll taxes, records and a first 90 days plan.

In this guide
- Do you need an employee at all?
- Set up the business to be an employer
- Plan the role and know the real cost
- Write the job and recruit fairly
- Interview and choose
- The offer and the new-hire paperwork
- Paying people and payroll taxes
- Records, policies and rules to follow
- The first 90 days
- Common mistakes
- Where WorkBOS fits
- Frequently asked questions
Hiring your first employee is one of the biggest steps a small business owner takes. It changes the nature of the business: you stop being only a doer and become a manager, an employer and a legal party to a set of obligations. The upside is large, because the right person gives you time back and lets the business grow beyond your own hours. The risk is also real, because a poor hire or a missed legal step can cost money, time and morale that a small business cannot easily spare.
This guide walks through the whole path in order, for businesses in the United States: deciding whether you need an employee or a contractor, getting set up as an employer, planning the role, recruiting fairly, interviewing, making the offer, completing the paperwork, running payroll and onboarding. Rules vary by state and by industry, and they change, so this is general information and not legal, tax or employment advice. Confirm the details with your state agencies, an accountant and, where needed, an employment lawyer.
Do you need an employee at all?
Before you write a job ad, check that you are hiring the right kind of worker. Many first-time employers try to hire an employee and treat them as a contractor to avoid payroll duties. That is risky. What matters is the real relationship, not what the contract is called.
Employee or independent contractor
The IRS explains that you generally must withhold and deposit income tax, Social Security tax and Medicare tax from employee wages, pay the employer share of Social Security and Medicare taxes and pay unemployment tax, while you generally do not withhold or pay these taxes on payments to independent contractors. Its page on independent contractor, self-employed or employee says that you look at the evidence of control and independence, in three groups:
- Behavioral: does the business control or have the right to control what the worker does and how they do the job?
- Financial: does the business control the money side, such as how the worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed and who supplies tools?
- Type of relationship: are there written contracts or employee-type benefits, does the relationship continue, and is the work a key part of the business?
The same page stresses that no single factor decides the matter and that you should document the factors you used. It also says a remote worker is an employee under the common-law rules if you can control what will be done and how, even if the worker chooses to work remotely. If it is still unclear, the IRS points to Form SS-8, which asks it to determine worker status.
In plain terms, a person who works set hours on your premises or systems, follows your methods, uses your tools and works only for you is probably an employee. A specialist who runs their own business, sets their own methods, serves several clients and invoices you for a result is more likely a contractor. Some states apply stricter tests than the federal common-law approach, so check your state labor department too.
When a contractor, part-timer or agency is the better first step
You do not have to start with a full-time employee. Options include:
| Option | Best for | Watch out for | |---|---|---| | Independent contractor | A defined project or specialist skill | Misclassification if you control how the work is done | | Part-time employee | Steady but limited hours | Still triggers payroll duties and the same rules | | Temporary or agency worker | Short peaks or trial periods | Higher hourly cost, less loyalty to your business | | Outsourced service (bookkeeping, IT, marketing) | Functions you do not need in-house | Dependency on one supplier; keep access to your own data | | Full-time employee | Ongoing, core work | The biggest commitment in cost and obligations |
If you are unsure, ask what happens if the person leaves. If the answer is "the work stops and I cannot replace them quickly", you may need more resilience, not just another pair of hands.
Set up the business to be an employer
Becoming an employer means registering with several bodies and setting up systems before the first payday. The order below saves rework.
- Form the business entity first, if you have not already. The IRS says that if you are creating a corporation or LLC, you should form it through the state before you apply for an employer identification number, because applying first can delay your application.
- Get an EIN. The IRS tool for getting an employer identification number is free, issues the number immediately online if the application is approved and warns you to beware of websites that charge for an EIN. It lists hiring employees among the cases where you generally need one. It also says you can apply for only one EIN per responsible party per day and that you cannot save and return later, because the session expires after 15 minutes of inactivity.
- Register for state taxes and insurance. Most states require employers to register for state income tax withholding where applicable, state unemployment insurance and workers' compensation coverage. The rules and agency names differ by state. Search for your state's "register as an employer" page and your state department of labor.
- Report new hires. Federal law requires states to run new-hire reporting programs for child support enforcement, and employers usually have a short window after each hire to report. Look up your state's new-hire reporting site and put the deadline in your hiring checklist.
- Choose a payroll method. You can run payroll yourself, use payroll software or hire a payroll service or your accountant. Most first-time employers are better off using a provider, because deposits and filings are strict and mistakes carry penalties.
- Get the right insurance. Besides workers' compensation, ask your broker about general liability and whether you need employment practices liability cover.
- Open a payroll process in your calendar. Put pay dates, deposit dates and filing dates into a shared calendar before you hire.
Display the required notices
Federal and state law require certain posters and notices in the workplace, and remote employers often must provide them electronically. The EEOC says on its small business resource page that you are required to keep certain employment records and to post information about discrimination laws, and it offers a free poster to download. Your state labor department publishes its own list.
Plan the role and know the real cost
A salary is only part of what an employee costs. Plan the full cost before you hire so that the new person improves your finances rather than straining them.
Count the full cost of one employee
- Gross pay, including any overtime or bonus.
- Employer payroll taxes. The IRS says employers must pay the employer share of Social Security and Medicare taxes and also pay federal unemployment tax from their own funds, and that employees do not have FUTA withheld from their pay. Your state will also levy unemployment insurance.
- Workers' compensation insurance.
- Benefits you choose or must offer, such as paid leave required in your state, health coverage or retirement contributions.
- Equipment, software licences, a workspace and any training.
- Recruiting costs such as ad fees or agency charges.
- Management time, which is the cost owners most often forget.
A useful rule of thumb is to model a total cost noticeably above the base wage and then check that the work the person does will generate more value than that. Use the cost-benefit check to make the decision explicit, and update your cash flow forecast so you can see whether you can carry the cost during the first months when the new person is still learning.
Define the role in a page
Write one page that answers: what outcomes will this person own, what tasks will they do each week, which tools will they use, who will they report to, and how will you know in 90 days that it is going well? If you cannot write that page, you are not ready to hire. Then turn it into a job description following the job description guide.
Decide pay with care
Check that your planned pay meets federal and state minimum wage and overtime rules. The rules about who is exempt from overtime depend on duties and salary level and are easy to get wrong, so confirm the classification with your state labor department or an adviser before you set a salary and call the job "exempt". Compare your offer with similar local roles so that you can recruit and keep people.
Write the job and recruit fairly
How you advertise and recruit is covered by anti-discrimination law from the first word of the ad. The EEOC's page on prohibited employment policies and practices says it is illegal to discriminate against an applicant or employee because of race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation and transgender status), national origin, age (40 or older), disability or genetic information, and that the law forbids discrimination in every aspect of employment. It adds that it is illegal to publish a job advertisement that shows a preference for, or discourages someone from applying because of, one of those characteristics. Its example is that an ad seeking "recent college graduates" can discourage older applicants.
Write an ad that describes the work
- Lead with the outcomes and the main duties, not a wish list of personal traits.
- Separate must-have skills from nice-to-have ones; long lists of requirements put off good candidates.
- State the pay range where practice or law requires it, and include working hours and location.
- Say how to apply and what the steps are, so candidates know what to expect.
- Avoid words that point to age, sex or other protected traits.
Spread your reach
The EEOC also notes that relying on word-of-mouth recruiting by a mostly one-group workforce can have a discriminatory effect. Post in more than one place, such as your own careers page, local job boards, community groups and industry sites, in addition to asking your network. Keep a simple log of where each applicant came from so you can see what works.
Handle applications consistently
Acknowledge every application, store résumés securely and keep a single record for each candidate. Decide your screening criteria before you read applications and apply them to everyone. Do not ask applicants for information that you do not need and could not lawfully use, such as their age or family plans. Applicants who need an accommodation to apply, for example a sign language interpreter, are entitled to reasonable help under federal law, so tell candidates who to contact.
Interview and choose
The most reliable way to improve hiring decisions without a large budget is to use the same structure with every candidate. Our guide on structured interviewing explains the method. In summary:
- List the four to six competencies the role really needs.
- Write the same set of questions for each, plus a short job-related exercise if it fits.
- Have two people interview, and score each answer on a simple scale straight afterwards, before comparing notes.
- Compare scores against the criteria, not against a gut feeling about who you would enjoy a coffee with.
- Document the reasons for the decision.
Keep tests and checks job-related
The EEOC says that tests must be necessary and related to the job and that an employer may not use a test that excludes people of a particular race or national origin, or people with disabilities. A practical work sample, such as drafting a short email for a communications role, is usually easier to defend than a general quiz.
Reference and background checks
Check references by asking each referee the same questions about reliability, results and working style. If you plan to run a criminal or credit background check through an outside company, there are federal and state rules about disclosure, written consent and what you must do if you decide not to hire someone because of the report. Some states and cities also limit when you can ask about criminal history. Use an established screening provider and get advice if you are unsure. The EEOC small business page also offers tips on how to consider an applicant's criminal record when hiring.
Decide and communicate
Tell the chosen candidate quickly, make the offer, and send a courteous note to the others. Keep applications and interview notes for the period the EEOC recordkeeping rules require, covered below.
The offer and the new-hire paperwork
A written offer avoids misunderstandings. It should state the job title, start date, pay and pay frequency, hours, work location, who the person reports to, whether employment is at-will if that is the case in your state, any probation period, benefits and any conditions such as a satisfactory reference or proof of work eligibility. Keep it short and clear. Have a lawyer review your template once, and reuse it.
The core federal forms
The IRS page on hiring employees lists what you must secure for each new hire:
| Item | What the IRS says | When | |---|---|---| | Proof of eligibility to work | Employers must verify identity and employment authorization using Form I-9 for every individual hired, citizens and noncitizens alike; both employer and employee complete it | At hire, within the deadlines set on the form | | Social Security number | You are required to get each employee's name and SSN for Form W-2; do not accept an ITIN in place of an SSN for work | At hire | | Withholding certificate | Have a signed Form W-4 on file for each employee and make it effective with the first wage payment | Before the first pay |
The same page says that if a new employee does not give you a completed Form W-4, you withhold tax as if the employee is single, and that a W-4 stays in effect until the employee gives you a new one. It also says that the Social Security Administration offers number verification if an employee does not have their card to hand. Do not ask for more documents than the form requires, and let the employee choose which acceptable documents to show, because over-asking can itself raise discrimination concerns.
State and benefit paperwork
Add the state withholding form if your state has one, the new-hire report, direct deposit authorisation, any benefit enrolment forms and an acknowledgement that the employee has received your handbook. Collect emergency contact details and agree how you will communicate.
New-hire checklist
- Signed offer letter returned.
- Form I-9 completed on time and filed separately from the personnel file.
- Form W-4 and state withholding form received.
- SSN recorded accurately for the W-2.
- New-hire report filed with the state.
- Added to payroll and given a pay date.
- Workers' compensation coverage confirmed.
- Handbook, policies and required notices provided.
- Equipment, logins and workspace ready for day one.
- First-week plan and a named buddy agreed.
Protect the data you now hold
Employee records contain exactly the data criminals want: Social Security numbers, bank details and addresses. Store the forms in a restricted folder visible only to those who need them, and use multi-factor authentication on payroll and email. NIST's Small Business Cybersecurity Corner gathers free resources from government agencies and nonprofit organizations that help small employers protect this kind of data, and our roles and permissions guide shows how to limit access.
Paying people and payroll taxes
Payroll is where first-time employers feel the weight of the change. It is manageable if you understand the pieces.
What you withhold and what you pay
According to the IRS page on understanding employment taxes:
- You generally withhold federal income tax from wages, using the employee's Form W-4 and the IRS withholding methods.
- You withhold Social Security and Medicare taxes from wages and pay the employer's share of those taxes.
- You withhold a further 0.9 percent Additional Medicare Tax on wages above $200,000 in a calendar year, with no employer match.
- You pay federal unemployment (FUTA) tax separately, from your own funds.
- Federal tax deposits must be made by electronic funds transfer, which you can do through your business tax account, IRS Direct Pay for businesses, the free EFTPS system, or through a payroll provider or financial institution that may charge a fee.
State and local taxes may also apply, so ask your state revenue and labor departments.
What you file and when
The IRS employment tax due dates page sets out the calendar. In summary:
| Form | What it reports | Typical due date | |---|---|---| | Form 941 | Quarterly wages and employment taxes | End of the month after each quarter: April 30, July 31, October 31, January 31 | | Form 944 | Annual alternative for very small employers, if the IRS has notified you | January 31 | | Form 940 | Annual federal unemployment tax | January 31 | | Form W-2 (with W-3) | Wages and taxes withheld for each employee | January 31, to employees and the Social Security Administration | | Form 1099-NEC | Payments to independent contractors above the threshold | January 31 |
The IRS says small employers with annual employment tax liabilities of $1,000 or less may file Form 944 if approved by the IRS, and that there are ten extra calendar days to file if you deposited all taxes on time. If a due date falls on a weekend or legal holiday, you can file on the next business day. Deadlines and thresholds change, so verify the current rules each year.
Wage and hour basics
Federal and state wage laws set minimum wage, overtime and rules on deductions and meal or rest breaks. Pay people on a regular schedule, give a pay statement, never make unlawful deductions and record hours accurately, including for salaried staff who are not exempt. Our guide on tracking attendance, time and leave shows a fair way to do this. Paid sick leave or other paid leave laws in your state or city may apply even at small sizes, which is why the employee handbook guide also covers leave.
Run a first payroll safely
Do a trial run with your payroll provider or software before the first real pay date. Check gross pay, each deduction, employer taxes, net pay and the deposit date. Get the employee to confirm their details in writing. Ask your accountant to review the first quarterly return.
Records, policies and rules to follow
Once you have employees, your record keeping obligations expand.
Keep the right records for the right time
The EEOC's recordkeeping requirements say that employers must keep all personnel or employment records for one year, and, if an employee is involuntarily terminated, for one year from the date of termination. Payroll records must be kept for three years under age discrimination and wage rules. If a charge of discrimination is filed, you must keep relevant records until it is finally resolved. Separately, the IRS says to keep employment tax records for at least four years. Our record keeping guide shows how to organise this, and keeps Form I-9 and medical information separate from the general personnel file.
Put the basics in writing
A short handbook beats an unwritten culture. Cover working hours, pay and expenses, leave and holidays, conduct and anti-harassment rules, how to raise a concern, use of equipment and data, and how performance is reviewed. The handbook guide provides an outline. Have an employment lawyer or state resource review it once, then update it yearly.
Treat people fairly and consistently
Write down how you handle complaints, discipline and termination, and follow the same steps for everyone. Document problems when they occur and the support you offered. Never retaliate against someone who raises a concern, which the EEOC identifies as unlawful as well. If you ever need to end employment, check state rules on final pay and notice, and take advice before acting if the situation is complicated.
The first 90 days
A structured start improves retention and productivity more than almost any other action after hiring. Our first 90 days guide provides a full plan. A concise version:
Before day one
Send a welcome message with the start time, location and what to bring. Prepare equipment, accounts and a desk or remote setup. Tell the team who is joining and what they will do.
Week one
Walk through the business, the customers and how work flows. Introduce the buddy. Set up the tools and show where files live. Agree two or three early wins. Review the handbook together and answer questions.
Days 30, 60 and 90
At 30 days, check understanding and fix gaps. At 60 days, review progress against early goals and widen responsibility. At 90 days, hold a more formal review, agree goals for the next quarter and decide whether any probation period ends. Keep each conversation short and written. The performance review guide describes a light, repeatable format.
Manage workload and wellbeing
New hires and their managers are both stretched in the first months. Do not load the newcomer with everything the previous process did badly. Use the guide on managing workload and avoiding burnout to keep expectations realistic, and check in often on how the person is coping.
Common mistakes
- Treating an employee as a contractor to save money. The IRS looks at the real relationship, and penalties and back taxes can be large.
- Hiring before knowing the full cost. Payroll taxes, insurance and management time add up.
- Skipping the EIN or state registrations. Fix these before the first payday, not after.
- Vague job ads and unstructured interviews. They produce biased decisions and weak hires.
- Asking questions that stray into protected topics. Keep every question tied to the job.
- Missing the Form I-9 or W-4. Both are required for every employee, and late discovery is hard to repair.
- Missing payroll deposits and filing dates. Use a provider and a shared calendar.
- No written policies. Silence leads to disputes about leave, hours and conduct.
- Throwing away records early. Retention periods exist for a reason.
- No onboarding. A person who spends the first week without a plan will wonder if they made a mistake.
Where WorkBOS fits
WorkBOS can host several parts of the process in one place: a job description and a careers page for applicants, a hiring pipeline that tracks candidates through your stages, documents and signing for offer letters and policy acknowledgements, attendance and leave records, performance appraisals, projects and tasks for onboarding checklists, and roles and permissions so that only the right people see personnel files. It does not run payroll or file payroll taxes for you, so you still need an accountant or payroll provider, and it does not replace legal advice. You can explore the features, see the pricing (a free plan covers up to five users), browse the docs or take a course in the Academy. For the wider picture of how these routines fit together, read our complete guide to running a small business back office.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Do I need an EIN before I hire my first employee? A: Generally yes. The IRS lists hiring employees among the cases where you need an EIN, and the number is free from the IRS. If you are forming an LLC or corporation, form it with the state first so the application is not delayed.
Q: What forms must every new employee complete? A: At minimum, Form I-9 to verify identity and work authorization and Form W-4 for federal withholding, plus your employee's name and Social Security number for payroll. States often add a withholding form and a new-hire report.
Q: Can I just pay someone as a contractor to keep things simple? A: Only if they truly are one. The IRS tests behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. If you control how, when and where the work is done and the person works mainly for you, they are likely an employee and misclassification can be costly. You can ask the IRS for a determination on Form SS-8 if it is unclear.
Q: What payroll taxes does an employer pay? A: Employers withhold federal income tax, Social Security tax and Medicare tax from wages, pay the employer share of Social Security and Medicare taxes, and pay federal unemployment tax from their own funds. State payroll taxes may also apply.
Q: How long do I have to keep employee records? A: Federal EEOC rules say personnel records for at least one year and payroll records for three years, and the IRS says to keep employment tax records for at least four years. State rules may be longer, and records tied to a discrimination charge must be kept until the matter ends.
Q: Which questions should I avoid in interviews? A: Avoid questions about protected characteristics such as age, religion, national origin, disability, pregnancy or family plans, and stick to what is needed to judge ability to do the job. The EEOC small business pages and short videos give examples.
Q: Is a part-time or seasonal worker handled differently? A: They are generally still employees, with the same paperwork, withholding and recordkeeping, though some benefits and thresholds may differ. Confirm minimum wage, overtime and scheduling rules in your state.
Q: Should I use a payroll provider? A: Most first-time employers benefit. Deposits and filings are strict, penalties apply to mistakes, and providers handle the calendar and forms. Ask exactly which filings the provider makes for you.
Sources are linked in the text above: IRS (independent contractor or employee, getting an EIN, hiring employees, understanding employment taxes, employment tax due dates), EEOC (prohibited practices, small business resource center, recordkeeping requirements), NIST Small Business Cybersecurity Corner.
Run it all from one place
Projects, clients, finance, people and AI employees in one system. Start free, no card needed.
Start free →