How to get customer reviews ethically: what the FTC and Google allow
A practical guide to getting customer reviews the honest way: what the FTC's review rule prohibits, what Google allows, a step-by-step asking process, and how to handle negative reviews.

Reviews are some of the most persuasive marketing a small business can have, and some of the easiest to get wrong. Since October 2024 there has also been a federal rule aimed squarely at fake and manipulated reviews, so "how do we get more reviews?" now has a legal side as well as a practical one.
This guide covers what the rule prohibits, what Google allows, and a simple, honest process for asking happy customers to share their experience. It is general information, not legal advice. If you are unsure about a specific practice, ask a lawyer.
The rules in plain English
The FTC's review rule
The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule took effect on October 21, 2024. The Federal Register notice published the final rule, which is codified at 16 CFR Part 465. In summary, it prohibits:
- Fake reviews and testimonials. You cannot write, buy or sell reviews that do not reflect a real customer's experience. A business can be liable for buying reviews it knew or should have known were fake.
- Paying for sentiment. Payment or incentives that are conditioned, openly or implicitly, on the review being positive or negative are off limits.
- Undisclosed insider reviews. Employees, owners and their close relatives must clearly disclose their connection if they post.
- Fake independence. You cannot run a review site that pretends to be independent of your company.
- Review suppression. Intimidation, false accusations against reviewers and baseless legal threats to stop or remove reviews are covered.
- Fake social media indicators. Buying bot followers or views is covered too.
Courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations, according to the FTC's rule guidance. Ordinary customer follow-up, and moderating reviews under neutral policies, is generally allowed.
Google's rules
Google applies its own policies, often stricter. Its prohibited and restricted content policy prohibits reviews that are not based on a real experience, including paid reviews. It also forbids incentives such as discounts or free items for a review, and it says you must not discourage negative reviews or selectively ask only happy customers. Staff should not be told to hit a set number of reviews, and customers should not be pressured to post on the premises or asked for specific wording.
A simple, honest way to ask
Step by step
- Deliver a good result first. Reviews follow experiences, so fix problems before you ask.
- Pick your moment. Ask right after a positive interaction: a finished job, a delivered order, a thank-you from the customer.
- Ask everyone, not just the happy ones. Selective asking is exactly what Google's policy warns against.
- Make it easy. Google lets you share a review link or QR code, and customers need a Google Account to post.
- Keep it neutral. "We'd value your honest feedback" is fine. Scripting what to say, or asking for five stars, is not.
- Offer no reward tied to the review. Not a discount, not a prize draw, not a free item.
- Reply to what you receive. Thank people, and address problems calmly.
- Log what you do. A short record of how and when you ask shows you are applying one neutral process.
Where to ask
| Channel | Good for | Watch out for | |---|---|---| | Follow-up email | Service businesses and online orders | Send to every customer, not a hand-picked list | | QR code at the counter | Shops and cafes | Do not pressure anyone to post on the spot | | Invoice or receipt note | Jobs completed in person | Keep wording neutral | | Text message | Appointment-based work | Respect consent and opt-outs |
Sample neutral wording
"Thanks for choosing us. If you have a minute, we'd appreciate an honest review so other customers know what to expect. Here is the link. Whatever you think, we read every one."
Handling negative reviews
Google's own advice is to treat critical reviews as feedback. Replies are public, so keep them professional, brief and relevant. Acknowledge real mistakes, explain what you can and cannot do, and apologise when it is warranted. Do not share private information or make personal attacks, and sign with your name or initials. Replies are not a place to push deals.
What not to do
Do not threaten the reviewer, accuse them without evidence, or offer money to change or remove their review. Google calls offering incentives to change or remove a negative review prohibited, and the FTC rule targets intimidation and baseless threats. If a review appears to break Google's content rules, flag it through the proper channel instead.
Use the feedback privately too
A short survey sent after each job will catch problems you can fix before a public review is written. That is not review gating if you still invite every customer to post publicly, but never use a private survey to steer only happy customers toward public sites.
Reviews you should not collect
- Reviews from friends, family or staff, unless the connection is clearly disclosed where the rules require it.
- Reviews written on someone's behalf.
- Reviews bought through a service.
- Reviews exchanged between businesses.
Common mistakes
- Offering a discount or entry into a prize draw for a review.
- Asking only customers you know are delighted.
- Telling staff they must collect a quota.
- Scripting the exact wording.
- Replying defensively or sharing a customer's details.
- Ignoring reviews for months.
- Hiring a cheap "reputation" service without asking how it gets reviews. You can be liable for what is done on your behalf.
Where WorkBOS fits
WorkBOS does not post or buy reviews, and it should not. It can help you ask consistently. Use forms and surveys to collect private feedback after a job, the CRM to track which customers you have asked and when, and automations to remind a team member to send the neutral request, with a person making the final call. If you use AI agents to draft replies, they act only with human approval. See pricing and the docs to get started. Reviews also help local search, so pair this with the local SEO and Google Business Profile guide, and see the email marketing rules before sending requests by email.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Can I give a discount for leaving a review? A: No. Google prohibits incentives for reviews, and the FTC rule bars payment conditioned on a positive or negative review.
Q: Can I ask only my happy customers? A: Avoid it. Google's policy says you should not selectively ask only happy customers.
Q: Can my employees leave reviews? A: Insiders must clearly disclose their relationship if they post, under the FTC rule, and Google disallows reviews not based on a real, independent customer experience. The safest course is for staff not to post.
Q: What if a review is fake? A: Flag it through Google's tools and reply calmly. Do not retaliate against the reviewer.
Q: Is the FTC rule a risk for a very small business? A: It applies to businesses of any size, but honest practices keep you safe.
Sources are linked in the text above: the Federal Register (FTC final rule), the FTC consumer reviews and testimonials Q&A, and Google Business Profile Help.
Run it all from one place
Projects, clients, finance, people and AI employees in one system. Start free, no card needed.
Start free →