Pro free for 30 days.No card.Start free →

Shipping and returns policies for an online store: what to put in them

How to write shipping and returns policies for an online store: set handling times and rates, understand the FTC rule on delivery promises and delays, write a clear refund policy, and keep the records that protect you.

By WorkBOS Content Desk8 min read
Stack of cardboard parcels packed and ready to ship (Photo by promil69 on Pixabay)
Photo: promil69 / Pixabay

Few things shape a customer's opinion of an online store as much as two simple questions: when will it arrive, and what happens if I need to send it back? Clear answers build trust before the first purchase. Vague or missing answers lead to abandoned carts, angry emails and, eventually, disputes with the customer's card company.

This guide explains how to write shipping and returns policies for a small online store: what to decide, what the federal rule for online orders expects from you, how to handle delays, and how to keep records that protect you. It is general information for US sellers, not legal advice, and some rules differ by state or product type, so check yours before you publish.

Part 1: Decide how you will ship

Set your handling time and carriers

Handling time is the number of business days between payment and handing the parcel to the carrier. It is the one part of the delivery promise fully in your control, so choose a number you can meet on a bad week, not a good one. Then choose carriers that provide tracking and delivery confirmation. Stripe's guidance on preventing disputes advises using services with online tracking, giving customers the details as soon as they exist, and keeping in mind that card issuers do not click links, so any tracking evidence you submit later must be included as screenshots.

Price shipping honestly

You have four common options, each with trade-offs:

| Approach | Good for | Watch out for | |---|---|---| | Flat rate | Simple catalogues of similar size | Heavy or bulky items lose money | | Calculated by weight and zone | Mixed catalogues | Customers dislike surprise totals at checkout | | Free over a threshold | Raising average order value | You must cover the cost in your margins | | Free for all, built into price | Premium brands | Hard to sustain on low-margin items |

Whatever you choose, show the cost before the final checkout step. Unexpected charges at the last moment are a classic reason carts are abandoned.

Decide where you will ship

List the countries or regions you serve, and say whether you ship to PO boxes. International orders add customs forms, duties and longer delivery times, so many small sellers begin domestic only.

Part 2: Know the rule on delivery promises

In the US, the Federal Trade Commission enforces the Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule. The rule is in the federal regulations at 16 CFR 435.2, and the FTC publishes a business guide to it. In plain terms:

  • You need a reasonable basis for your shipping claim. If you state a delivery time, you must reasonably expect to meet it. If you state none, the rule treats 30 days from receiving a properly completed order as the default (50 days if the buyer applies for credit with the order).
  • "Usually" is risky. The FTC's guide says that if you advertise shipping within a set number of days "most of the time", you need a basis for believing you can ship within that time on every order.
  • If you cannot ship on time, you must tell the customer. Before the deadline you must offer a clear choice: agree to a delay, or cancel for a prompt refund. The notice should give a new shipping date, or say that you cannot give one, and provide a free way to respond.
  • Silence has rules. For a delay of 30 days or less, a customer who does not respond is treated as agreeing. For a longer or open-ended delay, the order is automatically cancelled unless the customer agrees or you ship within the time allowed.
  • Refund means refund. The FTC's guidance says that when you must refund an unshipped order, you cannot substitute store credit or gift cards for the customer's money, and it generally expects refunds to be made promptly, with seven working days given for most payment methods.
  • Keep records. Under the rule, the FTC can presume you had no reasonable basis for your claims if you cannot document your order-handling systems.

The FTC has brought cases against retailers for late shipping without proper notice and for offering gift cards instead of refunds, which is a good reminder that this rule is enforced.

A simple delay notice

If a delay happens, email the customer right away: say the order is delayed, give the new date (or say you cannot yet), say they can cancel for a full refund by clicking a link or replying, and say what happens if you hear nothing. Keep a copy.

Part 3: Write your shipping policy

A good shipping policy is short and covers:

  1. Where you ship.
  2. Handling time and the carrier options.
  3. Estimated delivery times and what is not included (weekends, holidays).
  4. Shipping costs and any free threshold.
  5. How customers receive tracking.
  6. What happens if a parcel is lost or damaged: report within a set number of days, and you will reship or refund.
  7. What happens with wrong addresses or failed deliveries.

Say "estimated" where times depend on a carrier, but only make promises you control.

Part 4: Write your returns and refund policy

Choose the basics

  • Return window. Common choices are 14, 30 or 60 days from delivery. State when the clock starts.
  • Condition. Say whether items must be unused, in original packaging, or with tags.
  • Who pays return postage. Free returns raise conversion but cost money. Some sellers charge a flat fee or deduct postage from the refund. Say it plainly.
  • Refund method. Original payment method is the clearest. If you offer exchanges or store credit as an alternative, present them as options rather than the default.
  • Refund timing. Give a realistic number of days after you receive and inspect the item. The FTC's consumer guidance says a seller should generally refund within seven business days of accepting a return for most payment types, so promising more than that creates a gap.
  • Exclusions. List items that cannot be returned for hygiene, safety or custom-made reasons, and say so on the product page too.
  • Damaged or wrong items. Offer a no-argument remedy and ask for a photo, which also helps you claim from the carrier or supplier.

Rules differ by place and product

Federal law does not set one nationwide return window for ordinary goods, but states differ on disclosure and some products (such as certain regulated goods) have special rules. Check your state's consumer protection office, and if you sell outside the US, check the rules there as well.

Make the policy visible

Show it on product pages, in the cart and in the checkout. Stripe advises having customers agree to full terms before paying, because a link alone may not persuade a card issuer that the customer saw it. If you later need to respond to a chargeback, the policy and proof of agreement are valuable evidence. Our guide to handling chargebacks and fraud covers this.

Part 5: Run the process, not just the page

A policy only works if someone operates it. Decide:

  • Who receives return requests, and where (an email address, a form).
  • How returned items are inspected, restocked or written off.
  • How refunds are issued and logged.
  • How returned stock gets added back to what you can sell, which matters if you sell in more than one place. See managing inventory across sales channels.
  • How returns data is reviewed monthly. A spike in "not as described" returns usually points to a photo or listing problem, which the guide to product photography and listings that sell addresses.

Remember that returns have a cash cost. Include a returns allowance in your budget.

Common mistakes

  • Promising next-day delivery you cannot guarantee.
  • Hiding shipping costs until the last step.
  • Missing or unhelpful policies, especially for refunds.
  • Offering store credit when the law or the customer expects money back, for example on an order you never shipped.
  • Not telling customers about a delay and hoping they will not notice.
  • No written record of shipments, notices and refunds.
  • Copying a policy from a larger retailer whose margins and systems differ from yours.

Where WorkBOS fits

WorkBOS is not a shipping or store platform, so labels and carrier tracking stay in your store tools. It is useful for the paperwork and the people behind them: tasks and projects can track a returns-handling routine with owners and due dates, chat and customer records in the CRM keep customer conversations in one place, invoicing and basic accounting help you record refunds against the right customer, and automations can remind a person to follow up on a delayed order, with any AI agent acting only after human approval. The docs explain each part, and pricing shows the plans. For a wider setup list, see our online store checklist.

Frequently asked questions

Q: How long do I have to ship an online order? A: If you state a shipping time, you need a reasonable basis to meet it. If you do not, the FTC's rule treats 30 days from receiving a complete order as the default. Faster is better for customers, but only promise what you can deliver.

Q: What must I do if an order will be late? A: Tell the customer before the deadline, give a new date or say you cannot yet, and offer a free, easy way to cancel for a full refund. Rules on silence differ for short and long delays.

Q: Am I required to accept returns? A: There is no single federal return window for ordinary goods, and states vary. A clear return policy is still good practice and helps with disputes. If an order never ships, a refund is required.

Q: Should I offer free returns? A: It can improve conversion but costs money. Many small sellers charge a flat return fee or deduct postage. Choose based on your margins and your return rate, and state it clearly.

Q: Can a customer dispute a charge for an order that never arrived? A: Yes. Under Regulation Z, charges for goods not delivered as agreed can be disputed as billing errors if the card issuer is notified within 60 days of the statement showing the charge. Good tracking records help you respond.

Sources are linked in the text above: 16 CFR 435.2 (via Cornell Law School), Stripe documentation, and FTC business and consumer guidance.

Run it all from one place

Projects, clients, finance, people and AI employees in one system. Start free, no card needed.

Start free →